Tula Benefits← All notes
Regulation

An open note to IRDAI's chairman

Meenu Singh · 8 October 2026

Dear Mr Ajay Seth,

What prompted this note was your interview on ET Now (27 September 2026), where you described the reforms as a win-win, with more affordability, more business and more income for everyone, including distributors.

I re-read the consultation paper with that line in mind, from the side of the employer who pays the group health premium. Three assumptions seem to carry more weight than the paper's evidence supports.

1. "More income for distributors"

The paper's levers are volume and scope: ₹10 lakh entry capital, non-insurance business, and a small-town top-up that applies to individual policies only. It does not estimate how much new volume would offset the cuts. In group health, commission moves from a 12% average (Part 2, ¶2.1.6) to a 2.5% cap for insurance distribution entities (Box 4A).

2. "Open architecture needs a lower cap"

Distribution entities get lower limits than agents "to create disincentive against commission-led sales". Yet the paper's own data shows brokers averaging 18% commission in general insurance, close to agents at 17%, while bank and NBFC corporate agents average 26% and 40% (Part 2, Annex 4, Table 3). Grouping them all together penalises choice itself. To me, that reads as a bias against the open-architecture distributor rather than against high cost.

3. "Insurance will become a pull product"

The evidence offered is better persistency for online purchases (Part 1, ¶48) and Bima Sugam still to come. But direct online business is about 2% of general insurance premium (¶68), and the paper itself keeps higher commission for products that are hard to sell . For a 200-employee company buying group health, I could not find how the pull would work.

Meanwhile, the larger problem the paper names, premium growth only keeping pace with GDP and coverage not widening (¶24–25), is one it says needs "reforms wider than the scope of this consultation paper" (¶157).

What would help the employer

The direction is right. The caps need the data to match.

Source: IRDAI consultation paper on insurance distribution, September 2026; ET Now interview, 27 September 2026. First published on LinkedIn, 8 October 2026.

Tula BenefitsIndependent advice on employee benefits in India for international companies, Global Capability Centres and growing firms. hello@tulabenefits.com · tulabenefits.com